Sunday
24Aug

Google loves post-click marketing

“Google loves post-click marketing!”

That was how Tom Leung from Google began his presentation on the Post-Click Marketing: Converting Search Engine Traffic panel at Search Engine Strategies (SES) San Jose this past week. How could that not bring a smile to our face?

For us, that really capped a phenomenal week where “post-click marketing” clearly emerged into the mainstream. After coining that phrase in the spring of 2005, our mission for the past 3 years has been to dramatically improve the effectiveness of online marketing by focusing on fresh ideas for landing pages, conversion paths, and microsites.

We’ve brought some unconventional thinking to the world of landing pages:

  • deploying multi-page landing experiences;
  • advocating A/B testing for its clarity and big-picture impact instead of MVT;
  • emphasizing one-click, self-segmentation by respondents;
  • incorporating Flash, widgets, and social media in landing pages;

What a difference a year makes! At SES in 2007, there was a lot of skepticism about these ideas. Most people we talked to believed that multivariate testing (MVT) would be the miracle cure for landing page performance.

This year, 2008, it was a completely different ball game.

A lot of people had tried MVT and not gotten the results they expected. It was becoming clear that three things really matter in post-click marketing:

  1. The freedom to rapidly create and deploy highly-targeted landing pages for specific ads — without IT or developer delays — to make sure that The Long Tail of online advertising didn’t ignominiously end in a Short Tail of generic landing pages.
  2. The power to run simple but high-impact A/B tests that any front-line marketer can easily implement and understand, rather than getting bogged down in more complicated MVT that all-too-frequently devolves into “let’s throw a bunch of random words and images against the wall”.
  3. The ability to segment respondents — either before the click or after the click — to deliver the right content to the right people and to optimize for each segment independently. (As Michele Hickford, our Director of Client Strategy says, “If you test for the average, you’ll get average results.”)

It also helped that we were able to show plenty of specific examples of this from Citrix, Bronto Software, CDC News, Overland Storage, the New England Journal of Medicine, Howard Johnson, American Greetings, Anthem, Millennium Bankcard — a big THANK YOU to all of our customers who let us share some of their success stories!

The bottom line: testing is important, to be sure. But it’s only successful if you test the right ideas for the right people. It’s a means, not an end. Post-click marketing > testing.

These topics kept coming up in a variety of sessions and conversations across the SES show. Many discussions about tapping into The Long Tail (or “the Mid Tail”) and segmenting respondents strategically ultimately led back to the need for segment-specific landing experiences. It was music to our ears!

Here are some excerpts and links to what other people had to say about the two panels we participated on:

  • Post-Click Marketing: Converting Search Engine Traffic
    • A summary from Susan Esparza of Bruce Clay, including this excellent remark attributed to Tom Leung of Google:
      “I’d agree about the power of A/B testing. At the end of the day, people get the best results from very small tests. Small tests make you focus. Multivariate tests can make you lose your focus.”
      Since Tom is the product manager for Google’s Website Optimizer, a free testing tool that supports both A/B and MVT, he’s surely seen thousands of examples of both kinds of tests. It’s great to hear that he’s independently come to the same conclusion we have.

After that session, I can say that post-click marketing loves Google too! ;-)


Thursday
21Aug

SEM Agency Snake Oil

Over the weekend I had this post stuck in my head. I couldn’t shake it. Then, on Monday, I read a post on SearchInsider by Didit’s Dave Pasternack titled Why Do All SEM Agencies ‘Sound The Same’?. That sealed it for me. I had to write my post. So here goes…

We’re in the post-click business. We handle what happens after someone clicks on a search ad, on a link in a promotional email, on an ad banner, etc. Being in the post-click space gives us a unique perspective and place in the client/agency ecosystem — right smack dab in the middle. We are often inserted in the lack of space between a client and their agencies. From there, one can see SEM houses in a whole new light.

To us, providing end-to-end transparency from ad to conversion is the holy grail. To most of the search agencies we encounter, that transparency is not what they want. Why? Because many SEM shops are not very good at what they do (see Dave’s #3 in his post). And if their clients find out that they’re not good, they’ll get fired. So, cloaking the practice in mystery  (in the form of Dave’s #1) serves them quite well. Think snake oil.

Again, to Dave’s point, I’m not indicting all SEM houses — just most of them. In fourteen years of online marketing, I’ve seen enough to make that statement with confidence.

If I play devil’s advocate, I can see their point. We have case study that documents a client of ours that cut their SEM spend from $480,000 per year to less than $160,000 per year. How? By gaining end-to-end visibility and trimming the fat. Today, they get a higher number of higher quality leads from 1/3 the spend. Not good if you’re the SEM firm that’s paid based on volume. But I only see their point for a few minutes. Then I consider the sustainability of a business model based on incompetence and I no longer side with the devil.

Organizations spend on marketing in order to generate more business — not to generate clicks. This spend must be made as efficient as possible. Search is no different than any other form of marketing. It must be accountable — not for clicks — but for business. Clicks are not results, they’re just a means to an end.

Instead of dodging to keep the winds of change from blowing away the smoke and mirrors, SEM shops should embrace the clarity. It’s sustainable to act in your clients’ best interests. And again to reference Dave’s post, it’s clearly a point of differentiation that they need.

It’s absolutely true that good post-click marketing provides upstream visibility. That visibility scares the hell out of most SEM agencies. Hire one that embraces that clarity and help move your business and the SEM industry forward.


Thursday
14Aug

Post-click marketing at SES San Jose 2008

We’re incredibly jazzed that at next week’s Search Engine Strategies (SES) show in San Jose, post-click marketing and landing pages 2.0 will be all over the conference.

Landing Page Utopia: Expert Roundtable

On Tuesday, August 19 at 4PM,  we’ll be on the panel for this session that will reveal some of the best secrets of landing page professionals. We’ll talk about 3 rock-your-socks landing pages 2.0 techniques that have consistently delivered double-digit conversion rates — including some of the latest uses of widgets and social media on landing pages.

Thanks to the generosity of a number of our customers, we’ll be able to show you a wide variety of real-world examples.

Post-Click Marketing: Converting Search Engine Traffic

Wow! On Thursday, August 21 at 1:30PM will be the first time a major conference has dedicated an entire session explicitly to post-click marketing — reflecting the increasing excitement in the industry for leveraging what happens AFTER the click as part of your overall search marketing strategy.

We’re thrilled to be on the panel with Carrie Hill of Blizzard Internet Marketing, Laura Wilson of the New England Journal of Medicine, and Tom Leung of Google. For our portion of the talk, we’ll focus on two things:

  1. A different (and more effective) kind of landing page optimization.
  2. A thorough look at self-segmentation after the click: how and why.

Landing Pages 2.0 at Booth #529

We’ll be exhibiting on Tuesday and Wednesday as well — please do stop by, meet the team, and pick up a copy of a landing pages 2.0 document that that will expand your mind (and your conversion rate) with 8 killer techniques.

Hope we see you there!


Friday
08Aug

Rich Media can boost landing pages conversions

What place does Flash and video have on a landing page? I think it depends a lot on context. If you have a big flash promo that takes several minutes to load right in the middle of your landing page, it may not be adding value to the experience and it’s probably inhibiting conversions. On the flip side, if you have something that loads fast and adds value to the experience, then it may be a big boost to your conversion rate.

Two weeks ago we injected a quick little flash product rotator on a client’s landing page and conversions jumped up almost 50%. Everything else remained the same on the page, we just swapped out a static product image with a rotating flash graphic. Big results from a relatively simple enhancement to the experience.

A few thoughts on adding rich media to your landing pages:

  1. Some rich media can add value to the experience—if it’s simple, fast loading and helps entice conversion.
  2. Some rich media is the experience—if a user is clicking on an advertisement about a product configurator, they probably expect that it’s going to launch them into a rich media experience.
  3. Rich media can be used as a reason to convert—for example, requiring a conversion in order to play an interactive game or to watch a webinar.

There’s  no reason to do rich media for rich media’s sake. Do it to add value, and the online conversions will follow.


Thursday
07Aug

Socializing B2B Lead Gen Conversions

As you can probably tell, we have a culture of experimentation here. Lately, one of the areas we’ve focused on is improving the quality and quantity of leads generated from B2B-targeted landing pages. These tests have involved inserting social features like micro-blogs, participatory white papers and micro-forums into landing pages.

Social Widgets in B2B Landing Pages

Micro-blogs and -forums are small-footprint widgets that we have inserted as part of the conversion process. These features have enabled respondents to deepen their engagement during conversion. They ask questions, post comments, request information, etc. We’ve seen 10-20% of converting respondents participate in these interactive, social widgets. This is not only a significant percentage, but also an indicator of a respondent’s level of interest. We flag their participation and forward that flag to sales as an indicator of readiness.

Socializing White Papers

Companies like our own — and about 25% of our client base — use white papers as fulfillment to entice respondents to convert. A challenge with white paper lead gen is that you get a lot of false positives — respondents do convert, and they do get your white paper, but seldom do they go much further.

There are two key opportunities in the white paper chain that can be tested and optimized. One is the delivery itself. We maximize the quality of our collected data by emailing the white paper (or a link to the white paper). This also gets us into our prospects’ inbox with another highly valuable, lasting impression. Next is the document itself. Typically white papers are delivered as PDFs. We do the same, but we pepper the PDF with interactive ‘buttons’ that encourage readers to participate in online conversations (more micro-blogs or -forums) or ask questions of the author (chat connections and/or more posts). What this does is extend the PDF back online, again deepening engagement and providing key indicators of sales readiness. The buttons link back to the web where more high-performance, socialized landing pages continue the subtle nurture process and let us move our best prospects closer to the sale.

Overall, our own B2B lead-gen performs consistently at over 22% average conversion rate. This includes paid search, house and third-party email marketing, and some online display advertising. Experimentation and socialization work. Nurture your own culture of experimentation and enjoy the results.